March 2, 2026
Driving on worn-out tires, especially in the winter, can be dangerous for you and others on the road. That’s why it’s important to know for yourself when you should replace your tires. Sliding into a snowbank, or worse, somebody else’s car, is not an option, so let’s take a look at how you can tell that your tires need to be replaced and how long you can expect to go between sets of tires.
Tire Replacement Frequency by Mileage and Tread Depth
There are all kinds of tires out there for every vehicle. From all-season tires to all-terrain and mud tires, they all have different life expectancies, performance benefits, and tread depths. First, let’s start with all-season tires.
All-Season Tires
All-season tires are ideal for everyday driving. Whether you’re driving a car, SUV, or truck, these tires are designed for highway driving at all times of the year. Because all-season tires are needed for everyday driving, they need to last longer on the road.
All-season tires can last anywhere from 40,000 to 80,000 miles. That’s roughly 3 to 6 years. Although we highly recommend you replace your tires every 6 years regardless of their appearance.
Tread depth is also important to assess before you go on long road trips or decide to go off-roading. If your all-season tires are worn down to a depth of 4/32 inch, that is when to replace those tires. The legal limit in the United States is 2/32 inches. If your tires ever reach that point, immediately replace them.
All-season tires are a great choice for drivers of all kinds, so make the most of your tires by keeping track of how many miles they’ve covered, their age, and their tread depth to minimize the risk of tire failure.
All-Terrain Tires
All-Terrain tires are a prime choice for enthusiasts who want to drive their off-road vehicle on the weekend but drive it to work on Monday too. The benefit of all-terrain tires is that they are designed for slick, off-road conditions but still give you the flexibility of being your daily driving tire without reducing ride quality on city streets.
They are constructed with tougher sidewalls than their all-season counterparts and have robust puncture resistance to keep the off-road fun rolling. They also last a similar length as all-season tires while offering that off-road edge.
Many all-terrain tires have a lifespan of 40,000 miles to 65,000. This is roughly 3 to 5 years of service without any adverse driving habits or towing overload.
Like All-Season tires, All-Terrain tires have a minimum tread depth of 2/32. If your All-Terrain tires reach 4/32 inches, you should make a plan to replace them soon.
Mud Tires
Mud tires are made for enthusiasts who want optimal traction in muddy conditions, so their off-road excursions don’t slow down. Often called mud terrain tires, these tire options are popular for their big, bulky, and aggressive look, making them great choices for show trucks and heavy off-road enthusiasts.
Mud tires can typically last between 20,000 and 40,000 miles. That may not seem like a lot, but mud tires aren’t supposed to be on your daily driver, they’re designed to tear up trails and not let thick mud stop them. Because mud tires are designed for off-road applications, these tires can last drivers a long time. The same rules apply for age of the tires, so after year six, you should treat yourself to some big, new mud tires.
Tires should be replaced every six years, no matter the mileage or tread depth. The wear and tear combined with the natural rubber degradation over time leads to the tire being less safe to drive. Being exposed to the elements for long periods of time like 6-10 years of use, reduces the tires’ strength and can show physical signs of damage like cracks or bulging along the sidewall. If you’re not sure how old your tires are, check for these signs and do routine checkups on how they look and perform.
How to Check Tire Wear Indicators at Home
Checking your tires once a month is a good way to reduce risk of tire failure and keep your tires lasting longer. Examine the tread wear and sidewalls for any irregular damage. If your tires aren’t holding air, you should check for punctures or cuts in the tread.
After inflating your tires, you can check for punctures with a water and soap mix after inflating the tire. Bubbles will form because of air entering the tire from that punctured area. If you’re worried about your tires tread depth or grip, there are several ways your tires can show they are wearing down and need to be replaced.
Signs You Need New Tires Sooner Than Recommended
Pressure Loss
One of the most common problems drivers run into is that their tire doesn’t retain the recommended tire pressure. If your tires are not holding air, they may have been punctured. Check your tires for any scrapes or holes. If you find any puncture marks that are smaller than a quarter of an inch in the tread, you can patch the hole and keep driving in comfort. If the hole is larger than that, in the sidewall, or entering the wheel at an angle, you should take them to a professional tire shop. They will most likely need to be replaced.
Tire Chunking
For off-roaders, tire chunking can be a common experience. Tire chunking happens when tires are driven off road for extended periods of time. Typically these drivers are roaming on trails or commonly ride and park on gravel roads. These rougher surfaces break down the tread of the tires. The treads will smooth out, patches will form, and even become flaky due to the consistent damage of those uneven, rugged terrains.
Tire chunking also occurs when mud terrain tires are driven on highways, since their thick tread blocks are not designed for pavement driving. Depending on the damage to the tires, you may need to replace them, but be safe and check them monthly to make sure they are not deteriorating where it might cause tire failure.
Irregular Tire Wear
If your tire looks smoother in some places but uneven across the tread, this may be a sign of irregular tire wear. This is usually caused by worn suspension, a tire belt separation, or the vehicle hasn’t had a tire rotation in a long time.
If the belt plies in the tire’s inner liner starts to separate and allow air into that open space, this can lead to irregular tire wear. If this issue continues, it can lead to the tire deteriorating and causing safety problems.
A worn suspension can cause more “jumping” as a car drives across the road. Tires are designed to be driven across flat surfaces most of the time, and a worn suspension takes longer to adjust to the original level, causing uneven surface tension on the tire, which wears down the tire unevenly. Driving with a worn suspension system is a bad idea, so bring it into a shop to make sure you’ll be able to drive your vehicle safely.
Dry Rot
Dry rot can be common for tires that are exposed to hot temperatures and direct sunlight. The tire will look very dry and small cracks will form, typically in small groups or patches on the part of the tire that is most exposed to sunlight throughout the day. This is something to watch out for if you’ve been eyeing up that old beater that’s been sitting in someone’s front yard all year. Do your due diligence and make sure your tires are ready for the journey.
Sidewall Bulge
If you’ve noticed your tires aren’t performing like they used to, and you recently hit some debris on the way to work or your last trail run, it may be a sidewall bulge. When you make an impact with a heavy object, the sidewall can expand outwardly. This bulge is also called an impact bubble. Once the sidewall plies separate from impact and let air into the tire, it forms that bulge. You cannot repair this issue, so you will need to replace them as soon as possible. Be safe out there!
Torque Cracks
Cracks from the treads into the sidewall are a sign of torque overload. Whether you have a heavy-duty vehicle that packs a ton of torque or have been hauling massive loads of gear, torque cracks are serious business. They should be replaced right away and the kind of abuse to the tires should be avoided as well.
Splices/Cuts
If you see any cuts or splices across your tire, it needs to be replaced immediately. Not only does the stopping power of the wheel diminish, but those tears threaten the integrity of the wheel, possibly resulting in a blowout. For your safety, take your car to the shop as soon as you see this in your tires.
Tire Lifespan by Brand and Type (All-Season vs Mud-Terrain)
Different tires have different tread lives. That’s why we want to compare some of the most popular all-season and mud tires on their tread life. All-season tires will last longer because of their daily use versus mud terrain tires that will have shorter lives but will last longer on the trails. Let’s compare!
All-Season Tires
Michelin
- Defender 2: 80,000 mile warranty
- Pilot Sport All-Season 4: 45,000 mile warranty
- CrossClimate2: 60,000 mile warranty
Bridgestone
- Ecopia EP422 Plus: 70,000 mile warranty
- Turanza LS100: 50,000 mile warranty
- WeatherPeak: 70,000 mile warranty
Goodyear
- Eagle® F1 All Season: 45,000 mile warranty
- Assurance WeatherReady® 2: 60,000 mile warranty
- Assurance MaxLife®2: 80,000 mile warranty
Mud Terrain Tires
BFGoodrich
- Mud-Terrain T/A KM2: 6 years
- Mud-Terrain T/A KM3: 6 years
- Mud-Terrain T/A KM3 UTV: 6 years
Toyo
- Mud-Terrain T/A KM2: 6 years
Nitto
- Mud Grappler: 20-40,000 miles
- Trail Grappler: 45,000 miles
Falken
- Mud-Terrain T/A KM2: 6 years
Shop New Tires at Only Tires Today!
Are you tires in need of a replacement? We have you covered. Our tire inventory is the largest in the world, stocked with tires of all brands and sizes to help you find the perfect fit. Visit our website, plug in your vehicle's year, make, and model, and let us find you the best tires for your car, truck, or SUV.
